TLDR: As an IT consultant, optimizing your tax savings is crucial for financial success. One significant decision you’ll face is whether to work as a 1099 independent contractor or establish an S-Corporation. By carefully managing the balance between salary and distributions can lead to substantial tax savings for small business owners.

If you’re more of a video person, then the video below is for you.

This article explores the key differences between these two structures and provides detailed examples of how to calculate tax savings on revenue. Before diving into the calculations, we’ll clarify important concepts and provide actionable takeaways to help you make an informed decision.

Key Concepts to Understand Tax Savings

1. 1099 Independent Contractor:
   • Individuals who work as independent contractors receive Form 1099-NEC from clients.
   • Income is reported on Schedule C of their personal tax return (Form 1040).
   • Self-employment tax is applicable, which includes both the employer and employee’s share of Social Security and Medicare taxes.
2. S-Corporation:
   • An S-Corporation is a separate legal entity.
   • Owners (shareholders) report income on their individual tax returns.
   • S-Corporations can offer tax advantages, such as reduced self-employment tax.
3. Self-Employment Tax:
   • Self-employment tax covers Social Security and Medicare taxes for self-employed individuals.
   • It’s usually 15.3% of net earnings, but S-Corporation owners can potentially reduce this.
4. Salary vs. Distributions:
   • S-Corporation owners are required to set a reasonable salary based on income and profession.
   • S-corporation owners have more flexibility to receive income as a salary or distribution.
   • Salary is subject to payroll taxes, while distributions are not.

Key Takeaways:

1. S-Corporation Potential Tax Savings: Operating as an S-Corporation can lead to substantial tax savings for small business owners.
2. Salary-Distribution Balance: Finding the right balance between salary and distributions is crucial for optimizing tax savings.
3. Consult with a Tax Professional: Deciding between a 1099 and an S-Corporation structure can be complex. Seek advice from a tax professional to determine the best approach for your specific situation.

Calculating Tax Savings: 1099 vs. S-Corp

Now that you have a grasp of the key concepts, let’s dive into the calculations. We’ll use a hypothetical scenario and real-world figures to demonstrate how tax savings can vary between a 1099 independent contractor and an S-Corporation owner.

Scenario: Imagine you’re a successful small business owner, Mary, who operates as a marketing consultant. In the past year, Mary earned $100,000 in net profit from her business. We’ll explore how Mary’s tax liability differs when she operates as a 1099 independent contractor compared to when she forms an S-Corporation.

Mary as a 1099 Independent Contractor:

As a 1099 independent contractor, Mary reports her $100,000 net profit on Schedule C of her personal tax return (Form 1040). Here’s how her tax liability breaks down:

1. Income Tax:
   • Mary’s taxable income is $100,000.
   • Assuming a simplified tax rate of 22%, her income tax liability is $22,000.
2. Self-Employment Tax:
   • Self-employment tax includes the employer and employee portions of Social Security (12.4%) and Medicare (2.9%) taxes.
   • Mary’s net profit of $100,000 is subject to self-employment tax.
   • The self-employment tax liability is $100,000 * 15.3% = $15,300.

Total Tax Liability as a 1099 Independent Contractor: $22,000 (Income Tax) + $15,300 (Self-Employment Tax) = $37,300

Mary’s total tax liability as a 1099 independent contractor is $37,300.

Mary as an S-Corporation Owner:

Now, let’s examine how Mary’s tax liability changes when she operates her business as an S-Corporation. In this scenario, Mary decides to pay herself a reasonable salary of $40,000 and takes the remaining $60,000 as a distribution.

1. Salary Taxation:
   • Mary’s salary of $40,000 is subject to income tax at a rate of 22%.
   • Her income tax liability on the salary is $40,000 * 22% = $8,800.
2. Self-Employment Tax on Salary:
   • S-Corporation owners must pay payroll taxes on their salary.
   • The self-employment tax on Mary’s $40,000 salary is $40,000 * 15.3% = $6,120.
3. Distribution Taxation:
   • Distributions from an S-Corporation are not subject to payroll taxes.
   • Mary’s $60,000 distribution does not incur self-employment tax.

Total Tax Liability as an S-Corporation Owner: $8,800 (Income Tax on Salary) + $6,120 (Self-Employment Tax on Salary) = $14,920

Mary’s total tax liability as an S-Corporation owner is $14,920, significantly lower than her tax liability as a 1099 independent contractor.

Comparing Tax Savings:

Now that we have both tax liabilities calculated, let’s compare the tax savings Mary enjoys by operating as an S-Corporation owner:

Tax Savings = Tax Liability as 1099 – Tax Liability as S-Corp Tax Savings = $37,300 – $14,920 = $22,380

Mary’s tax savings by choosing the S-Corporation structure amounts to $22,380.

Additional Considerations for Mary:

1. Reasonable Salary: It’s important for Mary to ensure that her salary is reasonable for the services she provides. The IRS has guidelines for determining a reasonable salary for S-Corporation owners. Paying an unreasonably low salary can lead to IRS scrutiny.
2. Quarterly Estimated Taxes: As an S-Corporation owner, Mary will need to make quarterly estimated tax payments on her salary to cover income and self-employment tax liabilities.
3. Compliance: Mary must adhere to all tax and reporting requirements associated with S-Corporations, including maintaining accurate records, filing payroll tax forms, and submitting an S-Corporation tax return (Form 1120S).

Conclusion

Operating as an S-Corporation can lead to substantial tax savings for small business owners like Mary. By carefully managing the balance between salary and distributions, Mary was able to reduce her tax liability by over $22,000 compared to her status as a 1099 independent contractor. However, it’s important to consult with a tax professional to determine the best approach for your specific situation, as S-Corporation requirements and guidelines can be complex.

In summary, understanding the tax implications of your business structure is crucial for optimizing tax savings and ensuring long-term financial success. By making informed decisions and seeking professional guidance when needed, you can make the most of your hard-earned revenue while remaining compliant with tax regulations.

If you’ve found this article, we recommend you read our guide to getting started in C2C.